Nov. 16, 2026

How Turkey Took Over Thanksgiving

How Turkey Took Over Thanksgiving
How Turkey Took Over Thanksgiving
Deficient Vegans
How Turkey Took Over Thanksgiving

This week we go into Thanksgiving’s history, how turkey got involved, and provide some recommendations for vegan ways to observe.

National Day of Mourning (United American Indians of New England) – livestream info:
https://uaine.org/

Sponsor a Turkey

Support Native Communities

Chapters
0:05 Thanksgiving, Turkeys, and Marketing Myths
3:25 The Original Thanksgiving Table
14:20 Diplomacy, Mourning, and Whitewashed History
18:39 How Thanksgiving Became a National Holiday
21:40 Advertising Made Turkey the Main Event
26:26 Modern Turkeys: Bigger, Bred, and Unable to Fly
31:17 Turkey Farming’s Cost to Birds
34:33 Thanksgiving Food Waste and Emissions
38:25 Ways to Make Thanksgiving More Compassionate
45:50 Supporting Native Communities and Rethinking Thanksgiving
52:21 Bite-Sized Coaching: Squat Alternatives
58:11 High-Protein Holiday Recipes and Community Updates

How to Get In Touch

Deficient Vegans

Muscle Deficient Vegan - Fitness & Nutrition

Protein Deficient Vegan - Food & Recipes

00:05 - Thanksgiving, Turkeys, and Marketing Myths

03:25 - The Original Thanksgiving Table

14:20 - Diplomacy, Mourning, and Whitewashed History

18:39 - How Thanksgiving Became a National Holiday

21:40 - Advertising Made Turkey the Main Event

26:26 - Modern Turkeys: Bigger, Bred, and Unable to Fly

31:17 - Turkey Farming’s Cost to Birds

34:33 - Thanksgiving Food Waste and Emissions

38:25 - Ways to Make Thanksgiving More Compassionate

45:50 - Supporting Native Communities and Rethinking Thanksgiving

52:21 - Bite-Sized Coaching: Squat Alternatives

58:11 - High-Protein Holiday Recipes and Community Updates

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Welcome to the Deficient Vegans Podcast, episode 76. I'm the muscle deficient vegan here with the protein deficient vegan. Do you want to say hi?

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Hi. Hi, everybody.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

So this week, we're going to talk about who decided Thanksgiving needs a turkey.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I'm going to guess capitalism.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Oh, you're not too far off. But first up, new news.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

New news.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

So the first piece of news we have is that the capital of Argentina, which is Buenos Aires, approved a compassion law that requires education on animal protection at all educational institutions.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

That's actually amazing.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, it is really cool. This was actually approved unanimously by the city legislature, which as an American, I find mind-blowing.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I kind of want to move to Argentina after hearing this. I speak mildly bad Spanish.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

The Compassion Law includes five core pillars. They are recognition of animal sentience, responsibility of care towards animals and nature, prevention of mistreatment, coexistence in public spaces, and how to access animal health services, including veterinary care.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

That's so cool. I wonder how many, like, what the percentage of vegans is in Argentina. Like, you think it's higher than most other countries?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

For something like this to pass, I would have to think so, but I'm not exactly sure.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Isn't this where the goldfish thing happened?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

I think so. They're also working on a general animal sentience law. And then I saw some other things. Wow. So they're doing a lot down in Argentina.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

That's awesome. Yeah.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Next piece of news we have is that Daring Foods, who makes a bunch of like chicken products, fake chicken, obviously, products that I really like, has now released some quote unquote steak bites, which is their first product that is like fake beef oriented instead of fake chicken oriented.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I know I probably won't like it because I hate like fake steak and most fake beef.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

But yeah, I wonder how good it'll be because I know Beyond just put out some like steak bites and stuff too. Yeah, I think it's- Seems like a lot of companies are moving towards that.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Seems like it.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I think it's because of Juicy Marbles. They saw like the interest there and they're like-

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

That wouldn't surprise me.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Man, their stuff's pretty expensive. I've heard good things, but- Yeah. It's pretty pricey.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Daring's not that bad. I know for the bags of chicken, I think it's like $4,$5 for- And that's basically for two meals worth of chicken.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Not bad.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

And, I mean, their chicken is good enough that it stresses me out to eat it.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, it's really good. I like the Cajun a lot. But for the steak bites, you can only get those at Publix until at least early 2027, which is a store here in the U.S. I don't know if they're international or not.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, I'm not sure.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

And then for their macros, they do have those listed there. 15 grams of protein for 141 calories.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

It's actually really good. It's a little over 40%.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, pretty solid.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Not bad. Thank you.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

The last piece of news is that Scoops, which is a peanut protein powder brand, they received some additional funding to expand their product line. So if you're a fan of like these peanut protein powders, like we also use PB2 quite a bit.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, and PB Fit. I don't think I've ever had Scoops.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

I haven't seen it anywhere. Yeah. So maybe that's what part of their funding will expand to go to my store.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, I know PB2 and PB Fit are a little pricey, but like you can actually buy Anthony's peanut powder and that's a little bit cheaper.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. I think this is probably similar to Anthony's because it looks like it comes in a bag like protein powders.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, anything you can buy in a larger quantity is usually cheaper.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Especially this kind of specialty product.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Also, you can make some really good peanut butter cookies with peanut powder.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Oh, yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Those still have pretty decent macros.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, definitely. All right, so let's get into the main segment for the week. We're going to talk about Thanksgiving and who decided that Thanksgiving actually needs a turkey. Where did that idea come from? Do you have any thoughts before we get into it? Like any guesses?

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Any guesses? Um, I'm guessing corporations and capitalism, you know, very much like advertising and stuff.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Ooh, advertising. You know what I'm saying? That's an interesting guess.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I feel like it's a little bit like Thanksgiving to me. I like the sentiment, but it feels a bit like Valentine's Day.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Of like, they trick you into thinking like, oh, I need this, I need this, I need this. Yeah, yeah. Right?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

These specific things.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, yeah. And it has to look like a certain way and whatever. Yeah. But then there's something so ironic. I know we're not talking about Black Friday, but it's so ironic to me that like the Day of Thanks is followed by like the day of death stomping people for a Tickle Me Elmo.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Very bizarre.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

It is bizarre.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

And it's like impeded into actual Thanksgiving Thursday. Yeah. Like they keep opening earlier and earlier. That's true. I just find it ironic.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Well, we went to a story yesterday and it was like they're pre-Black Friday. Yeah. It already started, whatever that is.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I don't know. I've never been to a Black Friday. No. The idea of crowds makes me nauseous.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Anytime I go up to a store and I see a line outside, I have a better place to be.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

There's, like, nothing I want enough to, like, maybe get trampled to death.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

No. Oh, what was that movie that we watched?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Oh, man, yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

It was so good. It was, like, a bunch. I mean, it wasn't good because people died in it, but we like horror movies. It was a movie. It was a movie. And, yeah, it was Black Friday and people died on Black Friday. because, like, the door, I think, fell in or something. It was pretty good. It had Patrick Dempsey, right?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Oh, yeah, that's right.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Anyway, very off topic, but I think it's capitalism. What do you think it is?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Well, you know, I already know, so I don't want to give you spoilers. Oh, okay. But I think you're pretty warm there. Yeah, so if you think about a Thanksgiving dinner, typically you have the idea of, like, the giant turkey sitting in the middle of the table and a bunch of people are eating turkey and maybe people who, like, they only eat turkey once a year. So it's probably not because they really like turkey.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I will say, okay, so my family always had a turkey and it was like the last thing to get eaten as far as leftovers. And now I bowed out of eating dead animals at age 12. So I didn't have to partake in the awfulness of finishing up dry ass turkey leftovers. But I remember my dad would be like, come on, you guys got to eat. We got to eat this. like, it's just too much for one family. Do you know what I mean?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Oh, yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Was your family like that?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Uh, I mean, we ate- we ate the leftovers. We did finish them. It wasn't like-

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Did it feel like a chore, though?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

I don't think it felt like a chore.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Oh, okay.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

But it did last. Like, the turkey in the fridge was in there probably like a week.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, it's just too much.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

It's too much and nobody really likes it very much.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Right. It's definitely, um, that kind of turkey can get pretty dry, so you have to eat it with something else. I can't just eat like pieces of it.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Ew.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

So the turkey industry estimated last Thanksgiving, there were nearly 30 million turkeys. Across the whole year, the U.S. raised 193.5 million turkeys in 2025.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Wow.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

So just on, you're saying on one day, 30 million out of 193.5 million turkeys are consumed.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

That was the estimate, yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

That's insane.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, definitely. That is the biggest day for turkey.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Which is interesting because they sell turkey as like lunch meat year round. Like Subway and all kinds of, and just like the grocery store, you know? Right.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. Also, last year we did a podcast episode about kind of surviving Thanksgiving and what to eat and stuff like that. So if that's something you're interested in, you might go check that out. Here we're mostly going to talk about like how did turkey become this central piece of Thanksgiving.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

This is more like historic.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

A point of reference we'll use is the year 1621, which is when on the Plymouth Colony, like Plymouth Rock, basically, there were about 90 Wampanoag men, which was a Native American tribe, with their leader Massasoit, which is actually a title for a leader, but that's also what they called them. And about 50 English colonists, they ate and celebrated for about three days after the colony's harvest. So, that is kind of the picture that the kids get taught about, like, this was Thanksgiving, this was, like, the Native Americans and the colonists coming together.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

The people that stole their land.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Right. But, yeah, so that is what people think of as the first Thanksgiving. That wasn't really the first Thanksgiving. And, actually, Native Americans have, like, a couple different types of Thanksgiving for, like, different berries and different harvests and stuff like that. But this is the one that people think of.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Right. It's where, like, the Native Americans and the white colonists came together. Yeah. I feel like that was one of, like, the earliest things I was taught in school, like a child.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Right. Yeah. And it's also used in advertising quite a bit. So as far as, you know, what the Native Americans ate before that, there was not really a single diet for Native Americans. It depended on where they lived, if they were near a coast, if they were in the woods. They all ate differently. But for 1621 specifically, you're talking about the Wampanoag, which was in like southeastern Massachusetts around the area of Plymouth Rock. So there is a living history museum in Plymouth called the Plimoth Patuxet. It was formerly called Plimoth Plantation up until 2020. So if you've heard that name before, that is the museum up there. So a lot of information about like what happened during this time and these interactions comes from that museum. So according to the museum, farmed foods like corn and beans were about 70% of the Wampanoag diet and meat was actually less than 20%.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

How?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Well, it was a low percentage. And I think it was pretty important to them and they did favor it when they could get it. But as far as what they actually ate, you know, about 70% of that was not meat. And obviously we don't have any like nutritional surveys from back in the day. But the museum has done, you know, what research they can do to kind of gather this information. Corn was kind of the big staple back then. They also had beans, squash, nuts, and berries that were gathered. But they did have a lot of deer when they could get it. That was a pretty central, you know, food for the Wampanoag. They would go and hunt deer. They also had fish, shellfish, and wild birds. Interestingly, like, the wild birds that were referenced did not, like, specifically call out turkey in this, like, first meal back in 1621. But they just kind of assumed that there was turkey there because there was a lot of turkey in the area. Something they commonly grew was something referred to as the Three Sisters, which I've actually heard before looking in, like, gardening books and stuff. but it's when you grow corn, beans, and squash together.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Those are three of my favorite things.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

So the way that works is the beans climb the corn stalks to, you know, hold themselves up. Beans also add nitrogen to the soil, which the corn uses. And then squash keeps the weeds down and keeps the ground moist because of the big leaves.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Pretty genius. Yeah. Way cooler than monocropping.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. So the idea of Thanksgiving didn't come over with the colonists. The Wampanoag and some other native nations had like 13 moons or 13 Thanksgivings. So they had Thanksgivings for things like strawberries, green beans, tapping maple and trees and other stuff like that. So for about three days in the Plymouth Colony in the fall of 1621, the Native Americans came with about 90 people, like we said. The colonists had about 50 people left. There were actually like 102 who came over on the Mayflower. About half of those had died by this point.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, I think they're probably not used to the cold and like just the climate and stuff.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

But they didn't actually call it Thanksgiving. So this was all documented in a letter that was from somebody named Winslow. He didn't call it a Thanksgiving. He didn't mention that they did it on a regular basis. This was just a thing that happened for a couple of days after harvest. So a couple of things he said in his letter about this meeting was that the colonist had sent four men out on fowling, which means hunting birds, basically. It didn't specifically mention turkey. It just meant they were going to gather birds. The Wampanoag went out and killed five deer. And then that's all they really mentioned for the food that they ate. So all we really know that they ate was bird and deer. And everything else is kind of an assumption.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

It's so funny because I feel like they, I don't know, when we learned about it in like elementary school and stuff and just how it's portrayed in media, I feel like... And there's always this whole descriptiveness of it, right? Yeah. Like what they wore and what they ate and like how they met at this place and like shared whatever. And it sounds like all of that is kind of just baseless assumptions.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

I think a lot of it is probably educated guesses, but it's not documented. Yeah. Somebody else, William Bradford, had written that there was a great store of wild turkeys that same fall. But there was never a direct association of like we had those turkeys at this. Yeah. But they just assume. So, what kind of things do you think that we have for Thanksgiving today that they wouldn't have even recognized as food back then?

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Hmm. Okay. I think stuffing is maybe, like, I feel like they probably did stuff with, like, some sort of bread. So, I think that one's fair. I think anything with, like, dairy. Hmm, yeah. Right? Because, I mean, I don't think that they drank milk and stuff, right? So, like, anything that had cream, dairy, that kind of thing.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, I didn't see it mentioned, so.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. So, I think, I don't know, scallop potatoes would probably be pretty unrecognizable. Like, what the fuck is that?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

I was thinking pumpkin pie.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Pumpkin pie would be weird, yeah.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

I saw in one article I was reading and researching this that they didn't even really have, like, the ingredients they would need to make a pumpkin pie.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, and pumpkin pie is, like, that quintessential, like, Thanksgiving thing.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Right. Also, no cranberry sauce in 1621.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Did they have cranberries, though? Could they have mashed them up?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

They might have. They didn't mention that either, though. The cranberry sauce company sure wants you to think it was there.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. Green bean casserole with fried onions on top.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

No Tupperware.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Sweet potato casserole with brown sugar. Yeah, that would probably be like, what the fuck is that? Like...

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Like a pure dessert. Yeah, yeah. Like, one spoonful at that

Protein Deficient Vegan:

point. I think, uh... well, I mean, their turkeys would be unrecognizable the way that we bred them.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

That's true. Yeah, we'll talk about that a little bit.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

But yeah, that'll be... that was totally different.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I kind of feel like the whole table would just be like, what is this? Yeah, And like how much, right? Like how much it was because, yes, it sounds like they did have food, but I don't think they had like a ton. You know, I think like a modern day Thanksgiving is like gorge yourself until you can't walk. But back then it was probably like, OK, we have a we have food, like we'll eat together. But I don't think anyone was like gorging themselves saying that would also be different for them.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, I think so, too.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

If you're enjoying this episode and want to know when we have more episodes coming, you should like, subscribe, and maybe leave a comment. Do all the things. Thank you.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Some of the points now that maybe you didn't learn in the school version and doesn't really get taught to the kids is that the gathering was actually considered a diplomatic event. And it was held to keep up an alliance that they had made together. It wasn't because, like, we're all friends having a feast.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. Based on what I know, I can't imagine the Native Americans and the white colonists were ever friends.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

At least not on the Native American side, right?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. Also, the title of like the first Thanksgiving, which is how this is thought of, was added like 200 years later by an editor named Alexander Young, who added a footnote to the letter from Winslow. And he just said this was the first Thanksgiving. And then he also wrote they no doubt feasted on wild turkey. But those things were both just an editor making assumptions again.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Right, right.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

So, yeah, neither one of those is definitely true. It definitely wasn't the first Thanksgiving, but that maybe is the first thing that we think of as Thanksgiving.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I think the other thing that's lost when we talk about Thanksgiving in general is wasn't this first Thanksgiving meal or whatever. That was before they basically like stole land and committed a bunch of violence against Native Americans. I don't know. It's just weird to see it as like, oh, it's like this big friend dinner or whatever. And then like the rest of history gets whitewashed out of like what actually happened to the Native Americans and stuff. Yeah.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

And on that note, the United American Indians of New England actually hold a national day of mourning at noon on Cole's Hill in Plymouth on the day that we celebrate as Thanksgiving. And they've done that since 1970. So actually, if you're interested in that, they do live stream that. So it'll be live streamed this year. They say non-Native supporters are welcome, but only Indigenous people actually speak at the event.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

As it should be.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Also, the Wampanoag are still here and active. The Mashpee Wampanoag tribe has about 3,200 citizens and have their own annual Native American Thanksgiving. So, yeah, I think a lot of the stories we hear about Thanksgiving growing up as kids in America is definitely from like the colonist side. Yeah. But, you know, it was not really a friendly event in the original times, you know.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

What I've always thought was interesting, because I took AP U.S. History in high school, but then I also took other history classes that were more world-focused. And what I think is interesting, and maybe this is an American-specific thing, but it's like American school systems have no problem talking about the atrocities committed by other countries. But when it comes to like American atrocities that Americans committed, you know, like wiping out Native Americans and stealing their land, it's like we really like to sugarcoat what happened. Yeah. Or even just like the civil rights movement and the civil war and stuff. It's like all very whitewashed.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Because I guess they don't want kids growing up hating how America was founded. I don't really know what that is, but it definitely feels like everything is very sugarcoated when you're learning it in school. Like, I feel like I've learned so much since leaving school, just reading things on my own than I would have ever learned in school. And I, like, took AP U.S. History and, like, it was very, very whitewashed into, like... I was still shocked. I still am shocked learning stuff even, like, a couple years ago. There's, like, stuff you just did not learn in school, even if you took, like, the hard classes, like, college-level classes. So, I don't know. I feel like this is, like, one of those things where it's, like, the truth of it is horrific, right? Like, from the Native American's perspective, which is why you only hear, like, the colonist side in schools.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, I mean, until, you know, researching for this episode, I had never heard of the National Day of Mourning that they held. And so, I don't know, that's only been around since the 70s, but you still think it would be something that would come up.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. I will say, this is going to sound so stupid, but one of the first times I really had like an aha moment was watching that Buffy episode that's about Thanksgiving. Yeah. And where a Native American comes back and like haunts like white people with, I think it's like some kind of flu. Oh, yeah. You know that one? Yeah. And we're doing a rewatch of Buffy, so that's why I was thinking about it. But yeah, I was like, oh, and like Willow's very against Thanksgiving. And I'm like, oh, why is she against Thanksgiving? And you start looking shit up and you're like, oh, okay, that's fair.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

So as far as how Thanksgiving became a national holiday in the U.S., the story is actually a little weird. It was one lady, Sarah Josepha Hale, who was actually a magazine editor for Boston's Ladies' Magazine in 1827, which later was called, I think, Godey's Lady's Book or something like that. I don't know. You probably have read the lady book.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Oh, yeah. No, I'm very ladylike. So I've definitely read that.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

So she actually wrote a novel in 1827 called Northwood. And it talked about, you know, that the roasted turkey was like the main attraction of the occasion. And it was placed at the head of the table. That was a fictional book, right? But this idea, but it also had like beef and pork and mutton and goose and duck and chicken and all kinds of things on the table. But it was like turkey was the main event.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, okay. Oh, okay. So we're also into the patriarchy of this whole thing, right? Like of like women need to be good housewives and like... serve good things and do the proper ladylike things at the meals yeah.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

I didn't specifically come across that point of view but uh you know

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I mean, I'm just inferring based on what you said.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

So she actually pushed for a national Thanksgiving before we had one in her magazine for several years, and then in 1863 she wrote to Abraham Lincoln.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Man like he didn't have better things to do. Yeah.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

So this was literally in the middle of the Civil War.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Wow. Priorities.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

A week after he got her letter, he proclaimed the last Thursday of November to be Thanksgiving.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Okay. I need Abe and Sarah Josepha Hale to get their priorities together. That's insane.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. So she helped popularize this idea of, like, turkey being the main event and then also pushed to get Thanksgiving instituted as a national holiday. Okay, yeah. So the- the date wasn't really locked in for a long time. It was just kind of late, very late in November. Yeah, usually the last couple days of November. Um, but then, uh, FDR came through and moved Thanksgiving back a week because people were complaining that it was too close to Christmas. So this was in 1939, and they called it Franksgiving.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Wow, that sounds like something Trump would do. Trumpsgiving.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. Well, I don't know if he called it Franksgiving.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Oh, okay. Yeah. Um.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

But, yeah, so I guess the retail lobby was talking to his commerce secretary and said 12 to 15 percent of the entire annual retail trade happens between Thanksgiving and Christmas. So they needed that to be more days.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

The capitalism of it all starts in 1941.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. So they fixed it to the fourth Thursday in November in 1941 and signed it into law.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Okay. So I was right. Capitalism. And I didn't mention the patriarchy, but it sounds like the patriarchy had a play.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

So far, this is just how we got Thanksgiving. The turkey is a different.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. Okay. That's fair. Yeah.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

So now the way it was made as like a turkey type holiday was mostly advertising.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

For women. It's the patriarchy plus capitalism where all bad things happen.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

So Good Housekeeping ran ads, like, the meat that was for Thanksgiving, originally it was like turkey but also with duck, or turkey but also with chicken or goose or something like that. But then by the 1920s, turkey was basically the only meat that they advertised in Good Housekeeping for Thanksgiving. Okay, now obviously that doesn't mean that everybody stopped eating all that other stuff, but it was like a clear line of, like, when we're advertising Thanksgiving, we're advertising turkey. And Good Housekeeping was like a huge deal.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Well, yeah. I mean, do you want to be a good housekeeper or do you want to be a not so good housekeeper? Yes. So it's like good housekeepers would have turkey. Obviously.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

You're nailing it, really.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. Do you want to be one of those women who doesn't keep their house good?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. And so you were also right. Here's where capitalism comes in. So in 1936, there was basically a glut of turkeys. They had way too many turkeys and they weren't going to be able to sell them.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

So it's like the government cheese reserves.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. So the National Association of Food Chains ran a National Holidays Turkey ad campaign. So basically, they took this like huge oversupply of turkeys that was going to be like a problem for the people who raise turkeys financially. And they turned that into a sales increase of 46% at their association's grocery stores.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I hate it.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. So they like, you know, just spun this turkey surplus into like a huge Thanksgiving, everybody buys turkey extravaganza.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Wow.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, and it pretty much has just stuck since then.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

People are such sheeple.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. Also, the USDA had already started breeding a smaller turkey in 1934. Then they had a survey two years later that backed up their choice because they said 87% of home demand was for birds that were 8 to 15 pounds. And so the turkey that they ended up breeding for that was called a Beltsville small white. So it was like a smaller turkey, but it was still bred specifically for meat.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Okay.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Um, and then by 1965, the, a breed called the broad breasted white had taken over and obviously it just had like a lot more breast meat, which was the most popular meat on a turkey. So, yeah, do you think if the advertising campaign in Good Housekeeping had run goose as the primary thing that we'd be a goose for Thanksgiving every year?

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I definitely think that. Yeah. Yeah, I think that's part of the problem with, like, gender norms, societal expectations, that kind of thing. because, like, that's where ad- I feel like why those keep getting enforced is because advertising can take such advantage of that. Yeah. Where it's like, all we have to do is run an ad and tell women, like, if they don't have a turkey at their table, well, they're horrible housewives. And like, you know what I mean? And-

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

It's crazy because, like, people will defend things like this and be like, that's tradition.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. And-

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

It's like, what? It's not true. It was like an invented-

Protein Deficient Vegan:

It's an invented- Maybe it's a tradition now.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

But it's because a hundred years ago, somebody ran some ad campaigns.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. I've always kind of been against this. I feel like it's like, When it comes to tradition, I would rather keep the things that I genuinely like and add in new things that I genuinely like. And if there's something I don't really like personally, why would I keep doing it?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, I will say I've like across the course of us doing this podcast for the last few years, like a lot of the stuff we look into leads back to advertising.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, it's kind of crazy.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

And it's really unsettling, like how powerful like one advertising campaign can be to like change the course of the future.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. I think that's part of the problem, though, is, like, when you have a society built on, like, keeping up with the, what is that phrase? Keeping up with the whatever. The Joneses. The Joneses, yeah. Or the Kardashians, whatever. Oh, right. No one can keep up with them. They have mountains of money. But, yeah, like, keeping up with the Joneses, like, you look next door and, like, you want to be as good as your neighbor and you want to, like, have all the things your neighbor has. And it doesn't matter if you actually want them. You know, like you want your lawn to look green and perfect and you want like all of these things that they have so that you can feel like just as good or better. You know, like I feel like capitalism really takes advantage of that because they can force you to buy random ass shit that you maybe don't want or need.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

I think the new saying should be like, don't be like the Joneses.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, exactly. Do whatever the fuck you want.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. Yeah, so for Thanksgiving today, in terms of turkey, so in 2025, we mentioned there were like 193 million turkeys raised, which was 6.2 billion pounds of weight of turkey.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

That's fucking crazy.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

And that's worth about five and a half billion dollars. And they think it'll go up probably in 2026 from about 193 million to about 199 million.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Mm-hmm.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Also, I found this really interesting. There's a lot more turkey per person than there used to be. So back in 1950, there were about four and a half pounds of turkey per person.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

That seems like an insane amount anyways.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, it gets worse. It actually peaked in 1996 to 18.1 pounds of turkey per person.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

My eye is twitching.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

It's back down now in 2025 to about 13.2 pounds per person.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I wonder if 96 was like, I just kind of remember people were all about like ground turkey, like for burgers and for sausages and like removing beef. So I wonder if that was like where it peaked.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

It had a big push as like a healthier alternative for a while there. Yeah. So also, so the turkeys are obviously bred for size. There was a small university study that raised domestic and wild turkeys in the same pen. Yeah. The domestic turkeys reached about 18 kilograms, so that's, what, like 40-ish pounds?

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, it's very heavy for a bird that needs to fly. I feel like what I read was the modern turkeys can't fly because of how we've bred them. I went hiking once, and this turkey jumped out. I've never seen it. This is the only time in my life I've ever seen a wild turkey, but I'm, like, hiking in the woods. And there's this big brush pile, and I hear, like, rustling. and all of a sudden this fucking massive wild turkey pops out and it was like flapping and shit. And I was like, A, I didn't know there were wild turkeys, where I was. And also they can fly. It's crazy. Yeah.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Fun fact, wild turkeys can't fly very far, but they can fly at up to 55 miles an hour.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

That's as fast as a fucking car.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, that's pretty fast.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

That's insane.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

They're like cannonballs.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

That's a car on the highway. Oh my God, they could do some damage if they flew into you. That's like, what? 55 miles an hour? Or that just doesn't seem at all reasonable.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

It seems pretty bad.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Were they Superman? Like, what the fuck is that? Out of everything you've told me, that one is blowing my mind. 50, like, what? 60 miles an hour? A bird? A 40-pound bird? Yeah.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Well, probably not the 40-pound bird.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Oh, yeah, for sure. They said wild, they get about 5 kilograms, so 10 pounds. That's still a big-ass bird.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, so in the study they did, they they had the wild birds in the same pen and they got to about five kilograms about 10 pounds

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah oh right so like the domesticated turkey that has been genetically bred to be massive they can't really fly the way that wild turkeys can right.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah and interestingly so the the Domesticated turkeys are about three times bigger, but relative to their body weight, only the breast muscle was the part that was oversized.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, so they're just like really like lopsided. Really, if you think about it, just like proportionally on how you would want to move and be agile and stuff.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Stuff like this makes me really confused about all the people who are pushing back on lab grown food.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I know.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Because like this, this is lab grown food. I know. It just also lives and you can see it.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, they just don't get it. People are very misinformed about all of this, unfortunately.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. Also, the domesticated turkey's leg bones are shorter for their body size.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. This reminds me of, I can't remember which documentary it is, but there was that one guy that was like, it might have been eating animals. There was the last, like, natural, he naturally grew chickens and turkeys, like heritage chickens and turkeys back from the early 1900s. Right. And he was really big on all of my birds are like legitimately free roaming. Like they're not limited in space at all. They have like all of the space. They're outside all the time and they're not like modified to be like massive. Right. And I think, yeah, I don't know. I thought that was interesting because he was like, mine can actually fly.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. And mate.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

And mate. And yeah, they don't have to be artificially inseminated. I think that's really interesting. I don't think most people understand like how like mutated. Yeah. Like a lot of farm animals have become.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Especially the birds.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, the birds have gotten it really bad. I mean, they can barely like walk or fly. They can't naturally get pregnant. Yeah. It's all really sad.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. So the heritage breeds, they can mate, but basically the ones we've bred are all artificially inseminated at this point.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

They can't even like have sex. Yeah. For real.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Also, as far as their lifespan goes on farms, the hens go to market at about 14 weeks, which is somewhere around 20 pounds. And then Tom's, which is a male turkey, goes at about 18 weeks, around 38 pounds.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

That's so sad. 14 weeks and 18 weeks? But like a wild turkey can live past 10 years old.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, there's one breed that can live past 15. Now, to be fair, most wild turkeys do die pretty young from various things, including predators.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

But at least it's nature, right? Yeah. And they get freedom.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

And also like these turkeys are on a farm. They should be safe and be able to live for longer.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

What like three to three to four months three to five months that's not like a good life.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, I think the life expectancy of a wild turkey, the average life expectancy, is like a year and a half, but yeah, under the ideal circumstances they can live 10 to potentially 15 years, depending on the breed. Europe's food safety agency is trying to do some things for turkey welfare. Um, they want to try to push for more emphasis on leg health and less on weight gain in the breeding.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Right, because, like, their legs aren't capable of carrying how heavy they are based on like the genetic modifications.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Um, and they also say that beak trimming and toe trimming and some other things like that can be avoided with better housing.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. And a lot of that I think is done to like avoid them hurting each other. Yeah. But if you gave them space, that wouldn't even be an issue. You know what I mean?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

They didn't have something right on top of them all the time. Yeah. And, you know, every farm is different. Not everybody handles it the same way. Like you said, there was the guy on the movie.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

The last.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

The last good bird farmer.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Quote unquote good. Yeah.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Well, yeah. I mean, they still get it sold for meat, right?

Protein Deficient Vegan:

They're objectively better than all the others, which, yeah, nobody's good.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

But there's also a big issue with bird flu. About 18.7 million turkeys are affected by bird flu from 2022 through 2025. Wow. And that's based on data from the Farm Bureau.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

18.7 million? Yeah. Jeez.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

And then this last October, commercial turkey flocks were hit by bird flu. And typically when a flock gets infected, they will cull as many birds as they need to to stop the spread.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Which means slaughter. Right.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. Yeah. So yeah, basically, I mean, just because we want more turkey breast meat, we now have a bunch of turkeys that can't walk around, can't mate, can't do anything. They get, you know, their beaks cut and all kinds of bad stuff.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. And I mean, I think that's like the main takeaway, you know, that I think if more people understood the details of what it takes to raise turkeys for food, maybe some of those things would make them not want to eat them because it's like it's not just that they die young. It's not just that they're artificially bred. It's also that the small amount of life they have is not good. Right? Because we've, like, genetically bred them to be basically overweight in specific parts of their body. They can't carry their own weight. Yeah. Their legs are usually injured. And also they can't really fly. And they don't get to live any sort of natural life like they would have in the wild. Like, they actually have to, like, de-beak them to keep them from hurting each other just because they're so cramped. Yeah. It's all really upsetting. And for what? You can make seitan turkey.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. So another aspect of this is like food waste and to a certain extent, like the greenhouse gas footprint. Yeah. Food waste, though, is a really big issue. There's a nonprofit called ReFED that basically tries to reduce food waste and things like that. But they had an article about Thanksgiving specifically. They said 320 million pounds of food is wasted on Thanksgiving, which is worth about $550 million.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I 100% believe that. I mean... who needs a turkey that big like it's never made you will sure but like how much of that is turkey.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

About 40%, they said, is turkey.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

That's crazy.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. Well, it's because everybody, I think, like we're talking about earlier, like, people just make this turkey because you're supposed to. A lot of people don't like the turkey.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. Even when I was, like, not a vegetarian yet, I remember hating the turkey to the point where, like, my parents basically had to force me to take, like, the smallest piece that I would, like, actually eat, you know?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

40% of the food that gets thrown away from Thanksgiving is turkey. Why are we making turkeys?

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah it doesn't sound like people really like turkey.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, they said, uh, they did a survey, and 89% of hosts, which is like almost all of them, yeah, they intentionally make more food than they need to make sure there's enough or to have leftovers. Leftovers, I totally understand. Yeah. But I think a lot of that stuff doesn't actually end up getting eaten.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Right. And I think it's because, um, it's not just that you have leftovers. It's that you have leftovers for, like, eight different dishes, right? And, like, those eight different dishes' worth of leftovers can really only stay good in your fridge for like three days. Yeah, which is- which is actually why... So we don't go to Thanksgiving dinner at either of our families, but we basically do, like- well, since I'm a recipe creator, I'm, like, creating, like, holiday recipes and stuff. Throughout the months of November to December is basically us eating holiday food. Yeah. Um, but we don't ever have, like, an actual, like, day where we make a shit ton. It's more of, like, three to four weeks where I make our favorite hits and also some new recipes. Yeah.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

It's pretty great.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

But it's like, yeah, we have leftovers when I make them, because I make enough that it's a recipe on the website, right?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

We're planning, like, oh, we're gonna eat those for three days.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Okay, yeah, exactly. Meal prep. Yeah, it's like meal prep. Yeah. Pumpkin, pumpkin pie. Yeah. It's pretty hard to do that if you're, like, doing a whole event where you're picking like eight, nine, ten dishes and a big turkey. Like, how are you going to eat all that food amongst a couple people?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, and I know all of our big family Thanksgivings always ended with, oh, my God, please somebody take something home.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Oh, absolutely. It's always like, hey, will you take this? Will you take that? Yeah. It's like, why don't we just make less?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

And then people take it home because they want to be nice, and then they won't eat it. Yeah, exactly. I ate everything I took home. But, you know, there are people.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. Well, some of it you don't even like, right? And you're like, yeah, I'll take it home. Yeah, this was really good. Wink, wink.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

I don't take home things I don't like because I'm like, I'll take every last piece of the thing I did like. Also, if we look at Our World in Data had a study about greenhouse gases per 100 grams of different types of protein. So obviously the meat ones were the highest. Beef was like far and away the highest. It's like 49 kilograms of CO2 emissions per 100 grams of protein.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Which is fucking crazy.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Poultry, including turkey, is down at like 5.7 kilograms.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

But that's still way higher than like tofu, for instance, at like 1.9. Yeah. Or beans.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, or beans. Less than one.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Or peas, which is 0.44. Right. So you're looking at like three to 13 times higher than some vegan options. Right.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

And, you know, so if that is something you care about as far as emissions and your footprint go, then, yeah, meat is higher than most of these other alternatives, especially the ones we would typically have with like a vegan thing. Right. Swap your turkey out for a Tofurky and you've got like three times less emissions.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Now we wanted to talk about some of the things you can do this year as like a vegan for Thanksgiving to try to maybe offset some of this or help out in ways we can. So you can kind of pick whatever fits you. Some of these things might not make sense for you. Some of them will. Or maybe if you have some options or ideas that we didn't list here, you can comment those to us. We'd love to hear that. But the first thing you can do is sponsor a turkey.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Which we did today.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. So this is like a symbolic thing. You don't own the turkey. It's just like a farm sanctuary will have a sponsorship page for turkeys around Thanksgiving where you basically can pay and contribute to like the care of that turkey or potentially the whole flock of turkeys, depending on what you want to do. So we, a farm sanctuary is one that's a really popular sanctuary. It's been around for a long time. They have an adopt a turkey program. They've been doing this for 40 years this year. And you can adopt one turkey or you can adopt the whole flock. They have five different turkeys right now.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. And they have a quiz for your personality to see which turkey matches with your personality. Yeah. Which we took and we both got Julie the turkey.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, we both took it separately and got the same answer.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Even though we had different answers. Yeah. But we had enough similar answers because Julie is an introvert.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Would you, like, should I tell them Julie's story?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Let's hear all about Julie.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Okay. So Julie was going to be killed for Thanksgiving at four months old. But after her flockmates died, the lonely bird followed her guardian everywhere. Grieving Julie's search for a friend inspired a change of heart that saved her life. Julie is anxious about the world, but she's curious and kind, too. She's that friend who's in your inner circle for life once she warms up. She gets excited to see her caregivers and even likes to play these days. Julie's safe place is a friendship that feels like home. And she loves peaceful days with her buddy, Roberto.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Oh, Roberto. So that is from the Farm Sanctuary website on their bio about Julie.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

But they also have four other turkeys. Tutu. Brunnhilde. What are the other ones?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

They're crazy names. I can't remember.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

They're some really good names. Okay. So there's Griffin the lovebird. There's Brunnhilde the busy bee. Galadriel the dreamer. Julie the introvert, which is our turkey. And Tutu the bestie. So I'd really love it if you guys would take the turkey quiz and tell us which turkey you are in the comments.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Another option is the Woodstock Farm Sanctuary you can do it there as well there are also probably if you have a local sanctuary they probably do something similar to this we'll put the links for the ones we know of in the website at least for Farm Sanctuary and for the Woodstock Farm Sanctuary but it's kind of just a cool thing you can do on Thanksgiving to help support a farm sanctuary that saves some turkeys you can also potentially visit or volunteer at a sanctuary if they allow that kind of thing make sure you follow the rules Don't like assume you can do anything with the animals necessarily. They all have different rules. They all have different hours. They all have different needs.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. And I mean, some of them were probably in factory farms, so they might not be, you know, They might not like human interactions.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Right. And we'll also have a link for the Global Federation of Animal Sanctuaries. They keep a directory of like farm sanctuaries that meet its standards. If something's not on there, that doesn't mean it's bad. But if it is on there, that means it's at least been evaluated.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Something else you can do for Thanksgiving specifically is you can host the Thanksgiving and make it a vegan Thanksgiving. Yeah. Or you can just bring a dish if you have to go to somebody else's.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

You have a Friendsgiving. I know there are a lot of vegans that have other vegan friends and they just do a Friendsgiving instead of going to like their families for an omnivore Thanksgiving. So I think that's really cool. If you have like enough vegan people in your life or if you just have friends that will do vegan for the day.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Right.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

But yeah, I mean, absolutely. If you're going to an omnivore Thanksgiving, bring a really, really good vegan dish.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

So you can like maybe change some people's minds about if vegan food is good or not. They make Tofurky-type things. They have a Tofurky roast. I think Gardein has a roast. Whole Foods has its own brand of vegan roast. So there's like several options. I think I saw that Juicy Marbles had some sort of roast this year.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Oh, I didn't see that one yet.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

So yeah, there's like a few brands that have that. I think that would be a good alternative for a main. There's also like a ton of recipes around making your own like vegan turkey out of either seitan or tofu or tofu and vital wheat gluten.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

That kind of thing.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Then for sides, you have a lot of recipes on the website. We'll link to your Thanksgiving roundup. Do you have any particular ones that you'd recommend to take to people who aren't vegan?

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I think, okay, so one of the very first things that I made when going vegan was, was I veganized my dad's scallop potatoes because those were always my favorite growing up because I went vegetarian so young. So like by the time I was 12, I couldn't eat pretty much anything at Thanksgiving. And really, I couldn't really eat his scallop potatoes the way he normally makes them because he puts ham on them. But what he would do for me, since I couldn't eat most of the other food, is he would like take aluminum foil and like separate a fourth of the casserole dish. So I had like a separate section that did not have meat.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

That's clever.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

And he made like my little vegetarian scallop potatoes. So yeah, those were one of the first things I veganized. Because it was like, that's what my dad made and then he told me that's what his dad made. So, I mean, it's like a pretty basic recipe but it's like one of my favorites. And we took it, to their Thanksgiving, and my dad got seconds, so I feel like it's-

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Dad approved.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I think that one's a good one. Are there any of mine that you would take?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, I think the green bean casserole is really good. I don't think you can really tell the difference between that and a non-vegan version, so I would recommend that. Also, I really like your pumpkin pie. Yeah, especially now with the new crust.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, that one's- no, yeah, no. So the crust is TVP, so maybe- maybe your family couldn't get down with that.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Well, you also have, like- don't you have instructions in the recipe for, like, doing it just, like, don't use my crust, use a normal crust? Yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, if you want to use a normal crust, the filling's really good. Yeah. But I also have, like, a chocolate silken pie recipe, and I- we take that one to holiday dinners a lot.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Those are probably my top ones.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, and if you're just- if you're making it for vegans, you've got a bunch of sides like TVP stuffing, uh, mushroom gravy, green bean casserole like I mentioned. You do have pumpkin pie, pumpkin spice seitan, a bunch of stuff like...

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, All kinds of shit.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

You get a lot of Thanksgiving recipes.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I do. I like beige food quite a bit. But I think the other thing is if you're going, and I think we're going to have a holiday, how to survive the holidays episode probably next week. Yeah. But I would say like one tip I would give is that if you are making something for omnivores that's vegan... and they don't really normally eat vegan food, I would stay away from like vegan cheeses and vegan meats. Like kind of stay away from things that are very centered around vegan cheeses and vegan meats because that's when they start getting picky. You know what I mean? Like if you pick stuff that just doesn't have or that could be maybe normally made vegan with like a couple omissions, I think they tend to like it more. Yeah. Like chili. Chili is a really easy one to make vegan and most people don't complain about it. Yeah, they're not really, like, missing anything.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Chili is hard to miss on. You just say, oh, I brought chili, everybody's pretty happy. So yeah, that's hard to transport, but good to bring. Yes.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Very hard to transport.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Also, you know, we talked about Native Americans a lot during this episode, so you can do some things to support the Native communities around. Um, first of all, you can find out whose land you're on. There are a couple of different websites for that. I'll link one of them down in the show notes. It's called Native Land Digital. They're not official maps or like legal boundaries or anything. It's just kind of a research thing basically to understand how the tribes were connected and what land, you know, was associated with which tribes, things like that. There are also a bunch of Native-led food groups, the First Nations Development Institute, Native American Food Sovereignty Alliance, and a couple of others. I'll link some of those down in the show notes. You can watch that National Day of Mourning live stream on November 26th. And then, you know, just understand that obviously not all Native people see Thanksgiving the same way. So different people are going to have different opinions about everything. That's just how it is.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

And then I think another random thing that you could do is you could do a soup kitchen. Like, you know how a lot of soup kitchens will allow you to volunteer with a group to serve food on any specific day? Yeah. So you could pick one of those and you could whip up some kind of, like, a vegan feast. Yeah. You know?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. That'd be really cool.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. Or look at, like, food pantries and what they need and, like, donate vegan food products. Yeah.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Again, like you said, look at what they need. Don't just give them a bunch of stuff and try to, like, impose veganism on them. They usually list like what kind of stuff they need and just donate the vegan things that are on their list of things. So, yeah, basically there was like, you know, this all started as a gathering after a harvest. There was not really any definitive thing on whether turkey was there or not. It was not called Thanksgiving. Yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

They weren't like bro-ing out in Friends.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

It was not even the first Thanksgiving. Yeah. You know, they had Thanksgivings over in the like England and stuff like that. The Native Americans had their own Thanksgiving. So this was just like a one-time thing that kind of got popularized. And then, you know, advertising and capitalism and some editor got all over it and turned it into kind of what it is today.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, some warped, fucked up thing that forces you to buy a turkey you don't want to eat.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, and then everybody throws away. So I think the important things to try to focus on are like, you know, time with your friends or your family or things like that. It doesn't necessarily matter what food it is as long as you all have food you like and that fit like your preferences and beliefs and all that stuff.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Honestly, I would like to see a rebrand of Thanksgiving that did not focus on, like, the fake friendship between the Native Americans and the white colonists, and it was just, like, a day to give thanks for friends and family and didn't rely so heavily on that, like, story that didn't really fully happen, you know what I mean? Because, like, I think the sentiment of, like, it's a day to be grateful and thankful and show people that you love them, I think that's really cool. Yeah. I don't know why we have to, like, whitewash history and pretend something nice happened when it was like, there's a lot more to that story, you know? Um, I don't know. What do you think? Yeah.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

I mean the entire like educational system kind of leading you towards it having positive feelings about Pilgrims is very odd when you go back

Protein Deficient Vegan:

And look.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

at the historical context. Yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah those like those cutesy little pilgrims with their silly little hats and boots You know, just hugging Native Americans over a turkey and some squash. But we know the truth. Yeah.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

So, I mean, you know, we can still give thanks. Obviously, the concept of giving thanks is way before that meeting and way after that meeting still valuable. And so we can incorporate the things that are actually important out of that message.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

So, if you could redesign Thanksgiving without any advertising, what would your perfect Thanksgiving look like? And you can have a couple opinions on it.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, I think just, like you said, just some dedicated time to spend with, like, your family or your friends and just all hang out together, eat some good food. Like, there doesn't need to be anything specific, really. Like, we like certain Thanksgiving-type things, but because they're, like, they're good fall food,

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I guess. Yeah, it's like the only time of year that we make them. Right. And I think some of it's, especially with like the vegan versions, as you're having to make your own like mushroom soup and stuff, it just takes longer. So it's like I wouldn't normally make that during like a random Wednesday. Yeah. Right? Like it's like you slow down and you take your time to make like special foods that are like significant to memories and stuff.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

There are a lot of things that make sense. Like pumpkin is in season in the fall. Yeah. So sure. Yeah. Lots of pumpkin stuff. I like pumpkin stuff.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

But yeah. Me too.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Squash. Same thing. Pumpkin is a squash,

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Right? Yeah. I like that. So like the idea of like Thanksgiving just being, especially as a vegan, like a time to veganize foods that are like special to you around the holidays or like that your family made or whatever. But I also really like this idea of I knew someone and this was actually Christmas, not Thanksgiving, but they would pick a random country, each year for Christmas and then make a bunch of dishes from that country to celebrate Christmas instead of like the normal traditional Christmas foods. And I always thought that was really cool. It's just like totally not like a traditional thing, but it was like their tradition of like, oh, like this year is China. We're going to make like very specific Chinese foods. And like, I don't know. I always thought that was cool. That is cool. Like anything where you can make your own tradition that's like special to you, I think is cool.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

It doesn't have to be like what everyone else is doing.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

So I think that about wraps it up for the main segment. Hope you guys have a good Thanksgiving.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Tell us what your favorite side dishes are.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Oh, there you go. Yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I think it says a lot about a person with their favorite side dishes.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I'm not sure what it says. What's yours? What's yours? Oh, fuck. Um... It's either scalloped potatoes or green bean casserole. And I know not everyone likes green bean casserole, but for me, it's the crunchy little onions on top are like my favorite. Yeah. What about you?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Mine is pumpkin pie, I think, for sure. And then probably green bean casserole. You actually made some deviled potatoes the other day. That is like definitely at the top of my list now. Always liked deviled eggs. And you actually have a good deviled eggs recipe, too. But these deviled potatoes are really good.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

They were good. I know. We got to make those again. because I need pictures.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Obviously, your deviled egg recipe is not real eggs. It's like the, well, what is it?

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, it's like silken tofu.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, silken tofu and egg shape. Yeah. I mean, those taste just like deviled eggs.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, they're a little crazy.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, so cool. All right, well, that's it for the main segment. Let's go ahead and get into the bite-sized coaching. So if you guys don't know, I'm a personal trainer, so I try to do a little brief segment every week where I talk about something related to fitness and nutrition, something that might help you out with your workouts or your fitness journey or whatever. So you get to ask the question.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I do. And this question is actually a question I have. What exercises should I do if I hate squats? Because I, I fucking hate squats.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. So squats are one of the like movement patterns that you want to be able to do in your workout. But that does not necessarily mean that it has to be like a squat necessarily. So the movement patterns are basically like vertical pull, horizontal pull, horizontal push, maybe a vertical push, and then like a squat and a hip hinge. Like those are the kind of movement patterns that your body can do that you want to try to incorporate in some way. So squat is a major one, but it doesn't have to be like a barbell squat, like actual squat.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. I feel like with my body shape and my scoliosis, squats are damn near impossible for me to do in hold good form. And I've tried like, the like wedge and stuff and all kinds of shit to like get the form right and it's just like my body just doesn't move that way.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Also takes kind of a lot of time so if you're time limited trying to set up barbell squats and do the rest in between, it can take, like, a- like, when I do- like, when I have- I do squats a couple times a week in my workout, and when I do squats, like, just getting through my squats is probably like 30 minutes out of my- well,

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, because you do your warm-ups and you, like, gradually move up to get to the weight, because I think there's, like, the higher you get in weight, the harder or the longer it's going to take you, right?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

So yeah, some alternatives. So there are other types of variants of squats that people typically like more, even if they don't do, like, what we think of as squats, which are, like, the Bulgarian split squat, where you put your leg up behind you on a bench or something and do a one-legged squat and switch legs. There's also just normal split squats, like a lunge- like, well, there's a difference. A split squat is where you don't move your feet.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Okay, so lunge is where you're, like, a walking situation?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

You don't have to be walking, but you're moving your foot. Okay, so split squat is your feet are stationary. So you just like squat down, but your feet are apart. So you're doing it one leg at a time. You just squat down, squat down. So, and you can do that with dumbbells. You almost always do that with dumbbells. You can do it with a barbell, but it's very weird and precarious. So you can do that with dumbbells. And that'll be enough weight typically to do one leg. Then you can do lunges, which is like where you step forward with one leg and squat down.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Or step back.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Or step back and bring your foot. So you can do those. You can also do like you were kind of talking about walking lunges where you walk across the gym or the floor or whatever and you're doing one leg at a time. So all of those things are kind of the same movement pattern. There's still a squat. But really, you know, what you're targeting with a squat is like mostly the quadricep, like the front top of your leg. So if you like don't do any of those squat variants or you just really, really hate squats and lunges and anything that like has you dipping down like that, there are some other things you can do. A step up is actually a good one. That's kind of like a lunge, but up instead of going down. So you'll just have like a platform or something in front of you that you step up onto with one leg and then step back down. So that's basically the same as a lunge. Um, people like those sometimes better than lunges cause they're going up, which feels easier. Although they're really hard.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

They're really hard. Yeah.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Also, you have to find something you can stand on, which is the hard part.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Right. Cause the boxes freak me the fuck out. Yeah. I don't know why, but I just like envision, Hey, maybe this wood is actually not as good of shape as you think it is. Now my leg is now through a wooden box and like, yeah, I don't know. I've got some final destination thoughts, you know?

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, I prefer to do step-ups on something solid. Yeah. There's also, like, the leg extension where you're sitting on the machine.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

That's my preference.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Those are really good. They don't technically, like, it's not a compound thing. Yeah. You don't really have, like, all the different muscle groups inside the leg working that way. But it's still really good for your quadriceps. So I'd probably do that like with the others, but if that's the only one that you can really do, then that's fine to do those. The job of your quadricep is to like extend your leg. So if you think of like your knee is bent and now against weight, you straighten out your leg, that's what your quadricep is for. So any exercise that has you straightening out your leg against weight will kind of hit that muscle. I'd probably say that was probably about in order of like best replacement to worst replacement. So I'm good with that. You can also do, if you don't like barbell squats, you can do that hack squat machine at your gym, which is like a machine that you have shoulder pads and you kind of squat inside that. That's probably like the best replacement for a squat. I really like those. And sometimes those are a lot easier to get into.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Have you ever tried one of those hydraulic squat machines? A hydraulic? Yeah. We used to have one of them when I was in softball.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

As in without weight blades? Like actually like buttons hydraulic?

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. So no, it was like. It felt like ancient technology, okay? Okay. So basically, in softball, for some reason, our coach was also the football coach. So he trained us, like, the football team. Yeah. And just made us do weights and all kinds of crazy shit instead of, like, practicing skills, which is why we sucked. That's not important. But there was this, like, squat machine, okay? Okay. So you start down in squat position. Okay. And you're supposed to push up as hard as you can, as fast as you can.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Oh.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

But, like, the faster you push up, the harder it pushes you back down.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, yeah, I've seen those.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

And it would, like, bruise the shit out of my shoulders. I'd just go home with, like, my shoulders were completely black and blue.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, typically anything that involves, like, speed like that is, like, an athletic thing. Because that's power development more than strength development.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

But, yeah, that's really interesting. So those are some of the alternatives for squats. I would recommend you do something for your quadriceps. So did you have any updates in protein-deficient vegan land? You've been very busy in the kitchen, so I have to imagine the answer is yes.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

I have so many updates. Okay. So I have a couple new recipes. We have high-protein stuffing that uses the high-protein no-knead bread. And I'm not really a stuffing person normally other than, like, stovetop. You know, like, whenever I've had homemade stuffing, it's always disgusted me because it's always, like, soggy and, like, stodgy. I learned that on the Great British, I think, Bake Off. Yeah. The word stodgy, I really like it. dodgy. So yeah, I normally don't like stuffing, but this one is like, really good and it's moist but not soggy yeah so you should check that out if maybe you don't really normally like stuffing.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, that one's really good.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

And then I have a high-protein pumpkin pancake recipe that uses vital wheat gluten, and we've made that a lot and it's pretty good. And then I have a pumpkin sage high-protein bread recipe. Um, I don't- I feel like it has a similar texture to, like, focaccia bread. Yeah.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

That one's good to dip in some oil.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, it's really- get in, like, a- like, oil with, like, Italian seasoning. Delicious. You could also use it on a sandwich. Yeah. Um, but I have some more holiday recipes coming. Still working through a few more, getting pictures and videos, so yeah, a lot going on at the moment. I'm excited.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

This is my favorite time of year. You've always got so many things coming out of the kitchen in the fall. Yeah. Cool. All right, well, just a reminder: we have the Deficient Vegans Discord, which we have a link to down in the show notes. If you want to join, and, uh, join the community chat with people, talk about various things. We have channels for all kinds of different stuff now, like, uh, fitness and food, and a couple people even, like, organizing meetups in their local area, things like that.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, it's become pretty active. Pretty cool place. Uh, we will be voting on the next book club book probably in the next week or so. I need to get a list of which ones I'm gonna have everyone vote on, but, yeah, should be picking that one out, because the next book club will be probably like the second-ish week of January most likely.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. You get through the holidays.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah. Give everyone time to get the book if they want to join. But yeah, we'll be voting on that soon. So if you want to have a say in the next book club book, you should join. We also have a subreddit that's gotten pretty popular, the Deficient Vegan subreddit.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, we have a link to that down there as well in the show notes.

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Yeah, it's like maybe you're not a Discord person, but you use Reddit. That's like, you can find us there. Yeah.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Also, we have our websites, our social media, if you want to visit our, you know, individual things as well. Yeah, and if you're listening on Apple Podcasts or Spotify, if you could rate and follow and leave us a review, that helps us out a lot. And then if you are listening on YouTube or Spotify, you can leave a comment as well. Okay. Well, I think that's it. You want to say bye?

Protein Deficient Vegan:

Bye, guys.

Muscle Deficient Vegan:

Bye, everybody.